Im no expert but that sounds insane!
Did you you ever see what happened to Chris Pronger?
This is a discussion on Removed My Chest Plate off my CA within the Equipment Chat forums, part of the The Gear category; Has anyone removed the chest plate? I did, off my Brown 2200, i was sick and tired of it getting ...
Has anyone removed the chest plate?
I did, off my Brown 2200, i was sick and tired of it getting hung up on the shoulder floaters.
I think the brown chest on its own offers enough protection.
I am playing on 2 teams, SR A and a SR C.
I am hoping for no adverse side-effects from this.
well see, in a few weeks after the season starts if i have to put it back on.
I am hoping not.
Cheers
Jim
Im no expert but that sounds insane!
Did you you ever see what happened to Chris Pronger?
Chris Pronger was wearing shoulder protectors meant not to protect him from the puck but rather from bodily impact.
I've ALWAYS taken off the chest plate. I've always found them terribly annoying, and when the puck hits it, it always comes off weird since it's really hard foam/plastic. Can't feel or judge where the rebound will go. I first took it off on my old pro Brown (and, interestingly, recently sold the chest plate for like $40 on Ebay), and have since taken it off of a P1 and P2 pro, and I'm playing Adult Advanced and Adult "A" level hockey (mostly against old Juniors/College players, with a few ex pros mixed in). I have a Simmons M4 coming, and I'll consider taking it off of that one, too.
Can you sew it in on the inside?![]()
"Soccer players pretend they're hurt, Hockey players pretend they're not."
I think you could sew it inside if needed but what prompted me to finally say enough of the weird angles pucks come off it and it getting caught up on the shoulder floaters, was seeing the Kelly Hrudey pro return.
It is a brown with no chest plate, in the late 80's 90's they didnt have them and he survived the NHL.
the blocks feel solid so i am going with out . If i get some chest stingers i will add it back but make it smaller. the one on the 2200 is huge
from the neck almost to the belly button.
and it just seems like overkill.
with Syn, playing against the same level guys i am with no problem that makes me more comfortable with my decision.
Thanks
Cheers
Jim
I see what you are saying and im sure it is fine. Im just not one to remove safety equipment, after all im not going to make it in to the pro's at this point.
I figured the same thing as Jim: for years and years and years guys didn't wear chest protectors with these extra heart guards. I don't doubt it's SAFER with the heart guard, but I don't necessarily feel any more unsafe without it. Seems like a contradiction, but it's kind of akin to if you wore a big piece of concrete in front of you: you'd be safer wearing concrete, but you're also perfectly safe without the concrete.
I, like Jim, felt the weird bounces off the heart guard wasn't worth the extra protection.
Well I've got a guy on my team that can fire it 96MPH. I'm not willing to risk there's guys out there on other teams that can shoot harder.
"Soccer players pretend they're hurt, Hockey players pretend they're not."
Depends on what kind of 96 it is. I've faced guys who I have little doubt can hit 90s but it feels like a 50 mph snap shot.. just no real power behind it. Then I've faced those guys with 60 mph wrist shots but it feels like a 90 mph slapshot.. just a real heavy shot that's deceptively powerful. I do hate feeling those heavy shots right in the chest, but most often the guys with those shots are good enough not to aim right at me, haha.
Ive found that as well. I play with a guy who has an unbelievably hard wrist shot. He's the guy who keeps bruising my shoulder!
Before becoming a goalie i thought it was ridiculous to think that a goalie could get hurt through all that padding. I have all pro level gear and i still get the odd bruise and stinger. Oddly enough though i kind of like it. I guess thats what makes us goalies kind of wierd.
Bookmarks